Is this track record honest?
Upload a statement and get the checks experienced traders do by hand: sizing up after losses, averaging down, trades without a stop, stop-outs, how losers were held, deposit timing, and whether the results could be luck. Free, and the file is not kept.
What the check reads in a statement
The same rules EdgeWatchFX runs on live accounts, run on the closed trades in your file. A rule that needs a field the file does not have is not guessed: the result lists it as not checked and says why.
Lot size after losses
Martingale sizing: the next position grows after a losing one, so a long run of small wins hides the size of the bet that ends the run.
Averaging down
Grid trading: positions added at worse prices while earlier ones are still open. The whole basket is counted as one bet, not as a string of wins.
Trades without a stop-loss
How many positions were opened with no stop, so a single move could take far more than the usual loss.
Stop-outs
Positions the broker closed because margin ran out. A record that reached stop-out is not read as evidence of an edge.
Losers held against winners
Losing trades kept open much longer than winning ones, the habit of waiting for a loss to come back.
Large tail losses
Single losses far larger than the usual win, which a high win rate can hide for months.
Deposit timing
The time-weighted return next to the money actually gained on the money put in. A strong run on a small balance followed by a large deposit gives a good return and lost money; the check flags it.
Could it be luck?
The chance that the average result per trade was above zero, starting from a sceptical prior centred on no edge, and roughly how many more trades a firm claim would need.
Losses hidden in open trades
How far equity fell below the balance while losing positions were still open. This is where grids and martingales carry their risk.
Why a smooth statement can still be dangerous
Most track records are judged by a balance curve and a win rate. Both are built from closed trades. A strategy that adds to losing positions, or doubles its size after a loss, closes many small winners and keeps its losers open, so the balance climbs smoothly and the win rate looks excellent until one basket or one losing run takes back months of gains.
That is why this check looks at how the trades were placed before it looks at how much they made: lot size after losses, positions added at worse prices, stops, stop-outs and how long losers were held. A short profitable record is called what it is, good news that is still early, with the chance it came from luck stated in numbers.
What a file cannot tell you
- Losses carried in open trades, and the real equity drawdown.
- Whether the file was edited before it was uploaded.
- The distance to stop-out on positions open now.
Connecting the account with the read-only bridge EA measures all three. It cannot place, change or close a trade.
Track an account freeQuestions about the statement check
Is the statement check free?
Yes. It needs no account and no e-mail address. Upload a file and the result appears on this page.
Is my file stored?
No. The file is read in memory to work out the result and is not written anywhere, on the server or in this browser. The result exists only on your screen until you leave the page.
Which files can I check?
MetaTrader 5 reports and statements (HTML), MetaTrader 4 detailed statements (HTML), cTrader statements (HTML) and History exports (XLSX), and MQL5 signal trading histories (CSV), up to 5 MB and 20,000 trades. A MetaTrader 5 Strategy Tester report also works and is labelled as a backtest.
Can a statement be faked?
Yes. A statement is a file, and a file can be edited before it is uploaded, so every result here is marked as unverified. A record measured by the EdgeWatchFX bridge EA is sent from the terminal itself and signed with the account's key, and a public profile built from it can be checked on the verify page.
Why can a statement not show the real drawdown?
A statement lists closed trades. A grid or martingale closes its losing positions late, so its balance rises in small steps while the equity underneath can fall far below it. Those open losses never appear in a list of closed trades. Connecting the account measures equity every minute while positions are open, and rebuilds the earlier history from one-minute prices.
What do the Danger levels mean?
Each rule is rated Low, Elevated, High or Critical from what the file shows, worst first, with the figures behind it. A profitable record does not lower Danger, because Danger is about how the account trades, not how much it made. Rules a file cannot support are listed under "Not checked from this file" with the reason.
What does Withheld mean under Evidence?
When the record shows averaging down, sizing up after losses or a stop-out at a high level, its closed trades do not describe the risk it took, so its profit is not read as evidence of an edge. The figures the closed trades alone would give stay available, labelled as leaving that risk out.
Is the result a forecast or advice?
No. Every figure describes the recorded trades in the file. Nothing here says what an account or an EA will do next, and none of it is investment advice.
The full method, with sources, is on How EdgeWatchFX measures an account.
Where to get the file
- MT5: Toolbox, History tab, right-click, Report, HTML. A Strategy Tester report also works and is labelled as a backtest.
- MT4: Terminal, Account History, right-click, Save as Detailed Report.
- cTrader: History tab, Statement, or export the History as XLSX.
- MQL5 signal: On the signal page, Trading history, export to CSV.