EdgeWatchFXby ErgodicLabs

The RecordHidden risk

Losers held longer than winners: what holding time shows

Closing winners quickly and waiting for losers to come back keeps a closed record smooth and its win rate high, for as long as the losers come back. The holding time of winners and losers, set side by side, shows this pattern before the balance does.

4 min read

In short: compare how long winning trades were held with how long losing trades were held. When losers stayed open several times longer than winners, the strategy was taking profits quickly and waiting out losses. That keeps the win rate high and the closed balance smooth, and it moves the risk into the open positions, where a statement does not show it.

The pattern: the disposition effect

A trade goes into profit, and it is closed. A trade goes into loss, and it is left open in the hope that price comes back. Most of the time price does come back, at least partly, and the trade closes small or even positive. The record fills with winners.

The cost appears later. The losers that do not come back are closed far from their entry, sometimes by a stop-out, and they take back the profit of many small wins at once.

In people this is a well-studied habit. Shefrin and Statman named it the disposition effect in 1985: selling winners too early and riding losers too long. It is the opposite of the old rule to cut losses and let profits run. In EAs it is usually designed in: grids, averaging down, trades without a stop, and exit rules that close any profit but no loss.

A worked example

An EA wins 82% of its trades. Its winners were held a median of 2 hours and made 10 pips on average. Its losers were held a median of 9 hours and lost 45 pips on average.

Losers were held 4.5 times as long as winners. Per trade, the EA made 0.82 x 10 – 0.18 x 45 = 8.2 – 8.1 = about 0.1 pips. Its break-even win rate is 45 / 55 = 81.8%, and it won 82%.

The record shows an 82% win rate and a rising balance. Underneath, the strategy has almost no margin: a slightly larger average loss, or a slightly lower win rate, and it loses money. The holding times showed the shape of that before the expectancy did.

A strategy that takes wins quickly and waits out losers stays smooth for exactly as long as the losers come back.

Why holding time is an early signal

Holding time is visible from the first few trades. It does not need a large loss to have happened yet, and it does not depend on whether the period was a good one for the strategy. A record of 60 trades can already show that losers were held much longer than winners, long before it holds the one losing trade that would show what that habit costs.

It is also hard to hide. The win rate can be raised and the balance can be smoothed by holding losers, but holding them is exactly what this measure reads.

How to measure it

  • Use closed trades only, each with its open and close time.
  • Take the median holding time of winners and of losers. The median is better than the average here, because one position held for weeks would pull the average a long way.
  • Divide the losers’ median by the winners’ median. A ratio near 1 means both were held about as long. A ratio well above 1 means losers were given much more time.
  • Read the ratio together with the win rate. A high ratio with a high win rate is the pattern described here. A high ratio with a low win rate is unusual and worth a separate look.
  • For grids, count each basket as one trade, held from its first position to its last close.

When a high ratio is not a warning

Some strategies hold losers longer for sound reasons. A trend follower with a wide stop and a trailing exit can hold some losing trades for a long time while it waits for the trend to resume, and its large winners are held longer still. In that case the winners’ holding time is long too, the win rate is low, and the ratio stays moderate. The pattern to watch is the combination: quick winners, slow losers and a high win rate.

What it does to the drawdown

While losers are held, their loss sits in the open positions. The balance does not move, so a balance drawdown misses it. The equity drawdown, measured with the open losses, shows it. Records with a high holding time ratio are the ones where the two drawdown figures differ most. See equity drawdown vs balance drawdown and win rate vs expectancy.

How EdgeWatchFX reads it

Holding time asymmetry is one of the danger rules and one of the tests in the score. Losers held much longer than winners raise the danger level and count against the score; combined with a high win rate, the record check marks it as a fail. A grid basket counts as one trade. Each EA is compared with its own past as well: an EA that suddenly holds positions much longer than it used to is flagged as a change in behaviour. The same check runs on uploaded statements in the free statement check.

Figures in this note describe recorded results. None of it is a forecast or investment advice.

More from The Record