In short: balance drawdown is how far the balance fell from its peak, counting closed trades only. Equity drawdown is how far the account’s value fell from its peak, open positions included. When a strategy holds positions through losses, equity drawdown is the figure that shows the risk the account carried, and the balance figure can be a small part of it.
Balance and equity in one paragraph each
Balance is the money in the account after the trades that have closed. It changes only when a position closes, or when money is deposited or withdrawn.
Equity is the balance plus the profit or loss of every position still open. It changes with every tick while anything is open. It is what the account would be worth if everything were closed now, and it is what the broker uses for margin and stop-out.
When no position is open, the two are the same. The difference between them at any moment is the floating profit or loss; when it is negative, traders call it floating drawdown.
A worked example
An account starts with $10,000 and grows to a balance of $11,200. It then opens a few positions that go against it. At the worst moment the open positions are down $3,000 while the balance still reads $11,200.
| Moment | Balance | Equity |
|---|---|---|
| Peak before the trades | $11,200 | $11,200 |
| Worst point, positions open | $11,200 | $8,200 |
| Positions closed at a $400 loss | $10,800 | $10,800 |
The balance drawdown is $400 out of $11,200, or 3.6%. The equity drawdown is $3,000 out of $11,200, or 26.8%. Both describe the same account on the same day. Only one of them tells you that more than a quarter of the account was at risk.
Balance drawdown shows the losses that were closed. Equity drawdown shows the losses that were carried.
What the MT5 report calls them
The MetaTrader 5 strategy tester report prints three figures for the balance and the same three for equity. They answer different questions:
- Absolute drawdown: how far the line fell below the starting deposit. A strategy that never dipped below its first deposit shows 0, however deep its later falls were.
- Maximal drawdown: the largest fall from a peak to a later low, measured in money, with the percentage at that point beside it.
- Relative drawdown: the largest fall from a peak to a later low, measured in percent, with the money at that point beside it.
Maximal and relative can come from different moments. A fall from $2,000 to $1,500 early in a record is $500, or 25%. A fall from $20,000 to $17,000 later is $3,000, or 15%. The maximal drawdown is the $3,000 one; the relative drawdown is the 25% one. When someone quotes “the drawdown”, it is worth asking which of the six they mean.
For the risk question, the useful one is usually equity drawdown relative: the deepest fall in percent, open positions included.
Why a statement rarely shows equity drawdown
A trading statement is a list of closed trades, with the open positions at the moment it was printed. The equity in between was never written down. You can rebuild the balance line from a statement exactly. You cannot rebuild the equity line from it, because the prices that the open positions went through are not in the file.
Equity has to be measured while positions are open, or rebuilt afterwards from the deals and the price history of every open position. A tracker that records equity at intervals can miss a dip that happened between two readings, so an equity drawdown measured that way is a lower bound: the real low was at least that deep.
Which maximum drawdown to trust
For a strategy that closes every trade quickly with a stop-loss, the two figures are close, and either is fine. The gap opens up when positions are held through losses:
- Grids and averaging down, which add positions at worse prices and close the basket only when it is back in profit. See why a smooth balance curve can hide a grid.
- Martingale sizing, where the open loss of the last steps is large against the account. See reading a martingale from its statement.
- Trades without a stop-loss, and strategies that close winners quickly while losers are left open. See losers held longer than winners.
In all of these the balance line can look calm while the equity under it goes through deep falls. Prop firms know this, which is why most of them measure their loss limits on equity. See prop firm loss limits are measured on equity.
Four questions to ask about any drawdown figure
Balance or equity?
If it is not stated, assume balance. Most statements and many tracking pages only have closed trades to work from.
Measured at the low, or at the end of the day?
An end-of-day equity reading misses the intraday low. A position that went deep and came back before the close leaves no trace in it.
Is the peak ever reset?
Some reports measure from the starting deposit only, and some reset after a deposit. A drawdown that restarts after new money comes in can hide a fall that was fully paid for by the deposit. See when deposits flatter a return.
How long did it last?
Depth is half of the story. A 15% fall that recovered in a week and a 15% fall that took eight months to recover are different experiences for anyone following the account.
How EdgeWatchFX measures it
The bridge EA sends equity every minute while positions are open, with the lowest equity between readings. The history before the bridge was attached is rebuilt from each deal and the one-minute price of every open position, keeping each day’s low, wherever the terminal holds one-minute bars; days without them are marked as closed trades only. The maximum drawdown is measured at those lows against the running peak and is never reset by a deposit. Because equity is sampled rather than recorded continuously, it is shown as “at least” its value.
On the account page the drawdown bar shows both: the grey part is what the closed trades showed, the red part is what only the open losses showed. The method is described on how EdgeWatchFX measures an account.
Figures in this note describe recorded results. None of it is a forecast or investment advice.