In short: a track record is only as good as the path the data took to reach you. Screenshots and statement files prove very little on their own. Read-only access to the account, or data sent from the terminal to an independent service, proves much more. Even then, three things are worth checking yourself: whether the account is real money, how deposits shaped the return, and whether this is the only account that traded the strategy.
What is easy to fake
Screenshots
A screenshot of a terminal or a balance curve is a picture. It can be edited, taken from a demo account, or taken from a good week of a bad year. It says nothing that can be checked.
Statement files
MetaTrader and cTrader statements are HTML or spreadsheet files. They are convenient, and they are also text that anyone can open and change. A statement can be honest, but the file alone cannot show it.
Selected periods
Even an untouched statement can be printed for a chosen date range. A record that starts the week after a large loss looks very different from the same account printed from its first trade.
What an investor password proves
MetaTrader accounts have an investor password that gives read-only access: the history can be seen, nothing can be traded. Logging in with it, or connecting it to an independent service, shows the trades as the broker’s server holds them, on that broker and that account number. cTrader has no investor password; it has its own ways of sharing an account read-only.
That is a big step up from a file. It still leaves gaps:
- It shows that this account traded like this. It does not show that this is the only account, or the person’s typical one.
- It shows the account type if you look for it. Demo accounts can be connected too, and a demo fill is not a real one.
- It does not show who placed the trades, or whether the strategy behind them is the one being sold.
What a verified track record label usually covers
Tracking sites use the word verified for different things. On some it means the data came from the broker’s server rather than from an upload. On others it also means the person proved they control the account. It rarely means the strategy was checked for risk. When you see the label, it is worth finding out which of these it means on that site, and reading the record with that in mind.
Verified data tells you the trades happened. It does not tell you whether they were a good idea.
The account you are not shown
Suppose someone runs 20 accounts on strategies with no edge at all, each trade a coin flip, and shows you the best one after 100 trades. How likely is it that at least one of them won 60% of its trades or more?
For one account the chance is about 2.8%. For the best of 20, it is about 44%. Nearly half the time, a selection of strategies with no edge produces one record that looks skilled. Nothing in that record is fake; the selection is what misleads. This is why the length of a record, its number of trades and the way it was found matter as much as its numbers. See how many trades before a track record means something.
Deposits, withdrawals and the start date
A percentage return depends on how it was calculated. Money added after a loss, or withdrawn after a gain, can make a return look better or worse than the trading was. A record that shows a large return on a small first deposit, with most of the money added later, needs reading with care. See when deposits flatter a return.
Check where the record starts, too. If the account is older than the record, ask what happened before.
A checklist before you trust a record
- Where did the data come from: a file, a screenshot, read-only access, or the terminal itself?
- Is the account real money or demo, and on which broker and server?
- Does the record start at the account’s first trade?
- How large were deposits and withdrawals, and when?
- Is the drawdown measured on equity, open positions included? See equity drawdown vs balance drawdown.
- How many trades, over how many active weeks?
- Does the trading itself show sizing up after losses, averaging down, or trades without a stop?
- Is this the only account running the strategy?
How EdgeWatchFX handles it
An account on EdgeWatchFX is connected by a bridge EA running in the terminal. Each request it sends is signed with the account’s own key and bound to its login and server, and the record is marked Publisher, signed. Signed means the data came from the account holder’s own terminal, not that the broker confirmed it. Real-money accounts carry a Live status, and only live accounts can appear on the leaderboard.
A statement uploaded to the free statement check is marked unverified, holds closed trades only and is not kept; the result lists what a file could not show. Every published profile carries a reference that can be looked up on verify a profile, so a figure in a circulating copy can be compared with what was recorded when it was published. The methods are described on how EdgeWatchFX measures an account.
Figures in this note describe recorded results. None of it is a forecast or investment advice.