EdgeWatchFXby ErgodicLabs

The RecordHidden risk

Why a smooth balance curve can hide a grid

A balance only moves when a trade closes. A grid closes its winners and keeps its losers open, so its balance can climb in small steps while the equity under it falls a long way. Here is how that happens, and what to look at instead.

3 min read

Most track records are judged by one line: the balance after each closed trade. It is easy to read, it is what most statements print, and for many strategies it is a fair summary. For a grid it can be close to useless.

What a grid does

A grid EA opens a position, and when price moves against it, opens another one further away, and another, at set intervals. Each new position lowers the average entry price of the basket. When price comes back part of the way, the whole basket can be closed at a small profit.

Most of the time this works. Price wanders, comes back, and the basket closes in profit. Each close adds a small step to the balance. The record shows a long run of winners and a balance that rises almost in a straight line.

Why the balance cannot see the risk

The balance only changes when a position closes. While a basket is open and losing, nothing happens to the balance at all. The loss exists, the broker counts it against your margin, and it would be real money if the basket had to be closed, but the balance line stays where it was.

So the deepest point the account went through is not on the balance line. It is in the equity: the balance plus or minus everything still open. For a grid, the two can differ by a factor of five or ten.

The balance shows the risk that was closed. Equity shows the risk that was carried.

In the synthetic example on our What is different page, the balance never fell more than 4.9%. The equity, measured while the baskets were open, fell 36.7% in one basket. Both lines describe the same account over the same months.

What a closed-trade drawdown leaves out

Figure Closed balance Equity
Maximum drawdown 4.9% 36.7%
What it measures Losses that were closed Losses that were carried

A drawdown figure measured on the balance answers a narrow question: how much did closed trades take back from their peak. It does not say how close the account came to a margin call, or how much a trader following it would have had to sit through.

What to look at instead

The equity low of each day

The useful figure is the lowest equity of each day, set against the running peak. A statement does not hold it, because a statement lists closed trades. The terminal does: equity is visible every second while positions are open, and the past can be rebuilt from the deals and one-minute prices.

Positions added at worse prices

A grid leaves a pattern in its trades: positions by the same EA, on the same symbol and side, opened while earlier ones were still open, each at a worse price. Counting those, and counting each basket as one bet rather than as a string of wins, turns a 90% win rate into something much closer to what the strategy really did.

Losers held longer than winners

A grid closes winners quickly and holds losers until they come back. When losing positions were held several times longer than winning ones, the record is telling you how it made its money.

How EdgeWatchFX handles it

The bridge EA sends equity every minute while positions are open, and the history before it was attached is rebuilt from each deal and the one-minute price of every open position, keeping each day’s low. The maximum drawdown is measured at that low and never reset. Danger looks at positions added at worse prices, lot size after losses, stops, stop-outs and how long losers were held, and a basket counts once in every statistic.

None of this says a grid will fail. It says what the record carried, so you can decide whether you would have sat through it.

Figures in this note describe recorded results. None of it is a forecast or investment advice.

More from The Record

Hello world!

Welcome to WordPress. This is your first post. Edit or delete it, then start writing!

Uncategorized1 min read