Two numbers both get called the return of an account, and they answer different questions. When they disagree, the difference tells you something about the record that neither number says on its own.
Time-weighted return
The time-weighted return measures the strategy, not the money. It takes deposits and withdrawals out by chaining the results of each period between them. A deposit never counts as profit, and a withdrawal never counts as a loss. This is the right figure for comparing strategies, and it is what most trackers show.
Money gained on money put in
The other figure is plain: how much money came out of the account, or is still in it, against how much was put in. It is what the account holder actually made.
A worked example
Start with $1,000. The strategy makes 50%, so the account is at $1,500. At that point the holder deposits $10,000, for a balance of $11,500. The strategy then loses 10%, ending at $10,350.
| Figure | Result |
|---|---|
| Time-weighted return | +35% |
| Money put in | $11,000 |
| Money at the end | $10,350 |
| Money gained | -$650 |
The time-weighted return is +35%, and it is correct: the strategy’s results, chained, were +50% and then -10%. The holder lost $650, and that is correct too. The strong run happened on $1,000; the loss happened on $11,500.
The return describes the strategy. The money gained describes the account. A record that shows only the first can hide the second.
Why it matters for a track record
Timing deposits after a good run is common and usually innocent: people add money when something seems to work. But a seller can also start an account small, run it hard while it is small, and add money only once the return looks impressive. The percentage then says more about the first few months than about anything that happened with real size.
What to look for
- Both figures side by side. If they are close, deposits did not change the picture.
- A large gap, with the return far higher than the money gained, means the best results came while the account was small.
- The deposit dates against the equity curve. On a log scale, an early run on a small balance stays visible next to a later deposit.
How EdgeWatchFX shows it
Every account page and every statement check shows the time-weighted return next to the money gained on the money put in. When the return is far above the money gained, because the best results came while less money was in the account, a flag says so in plain words. Neither figure is hidden, because each is right about something.
Figures in this note describe recorded results. None of it is a forecast or investment advice.